السلام عليكم و رحمة الله 

All Praise be to Allah , Further more ..

we would like to Answer About Shaykh Al faateh Abu Muhammad Al Jawlany Hafidhahullah on why he did what He did and was it sin or not

Refutations to some of the doubts raised by Jama’at al-Baqdadi OR by their supporters:

Sheikh Jawlani disobeyed his Amir al-Baqdadi?

They say that the Amir of Jabhat al-Nusra, al-Sheikh al-Jawlani hafidahullah disobeyed and rejected the ruling of his Amir Abu Bakr al-Baqdadi when the latter announced the Islamic State in Iraq and Sham and that disobeying the Amir is not allowed for the soldier, hence the former erred and sinned.

We reply:
a) What Abu Bakr al-Baqdadi the leader of Jama’at al-Dawlat ordered is a sin and disobedience to Allah hence there is no obedience to any of the creation in disobedience to the Creator. We say it is a disobedience to Allah because the announcement was wrong in terms of the Shariah and also it was wrong in a political sense and it would lead to a disaster over the Jihad. And the reader should refer to what has passed in this text as to why the announcement was wrong in those two senses. Long story short, Abu Bakr al-Baqdadi a regional Amir had no privileges in announcing expansions and such without first seeking permission from his Amir Sheikh Ayman al-Zawahiri hafidahullah. And even if Sheikh al-Zawahiri was not the Amir of al-Baqdadi, we say that Sheikh al-Jawlani does not have to obey Baqdadi because he ordered disobedience to Allah. The obedience to the leaders is for the betterment of the Jihad and the Ummah, if the order of the leader is in direct contradiction to this and will only ruin the fruits of the Jihad and bring destruction to the Ummah, then such an order is against the wisdom of the legislation of obedience and thus in turn, the Maslahah of the Ummah and Jihad is given priority over the Maslahah of a group and its Amir.

b) If the soldier sees a strong doubt against the order of his Amir, he may pause obeying the order and take the matter back to an Amir of a higher rank. The evidence is that when the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wasallam sent Khalid bin al-Walid to Banu Jazima and the latter ordered that all the prisoners be killed. But Abdullah bin Umar refrained from obeying this order along with his companions and waited until they got back to the Messenger sallallahu alayhi wasallam in order to confirm the ruling from him. But the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wasallam disavowed from the ruling of Khalid bin al-Walid. May Allah be pleased with them all. Here we understand that if the Amir orders something which contains a strong doubt then the soldier may refrain from executing it until a higher Amir confirms it. And this is exactly what Sheikh al-Jawlani hafidahullah did when al-Baqdadi announced expansion of his “state” into Sham, the former halted from executing it and raised the matter back to the Amir of both of them, Sheikh Ayman al-Zawahiri hafidahullah. Thus the Sheikh al-Zawahiri ordered the annulment of the state in Sham to which al-Baqdadi refused.

c) If an Imam makes Ijtihad and makes a mistake, then he is forgiven. But if his mistake is made clear for him and he still persists upon his error, he is sinful. Whether he falls into the category of being sinful or forgiven, it is not allowed for others to blindly follow his mistake. Hence Sheikh al-Jawlani and the Shar’i committee of Jabhat al-Nusra announced their refusal to obey the order of Abu Bakr al-Baqdadi as he made a mistake in his announcement to which he was a Mujtahid doing Ijtihad. After that, his mistake was pointed out to him by the scholars of Jihad and the Mujahidin, yet he continued upon his error with baseless arguments and deductions far from the understanding of the Salaf. And he added to that other baseless arguments he used for shedding the blood of the Muslims and to Allah we complain.

By Abu Dujjana Al Maldify

[1]as for The Link About Abu Urwa we say How can you Also relate Dawlah to the Prophet Sala Allahu aleyh wasalem RIGHT Caliphate to One which at First said On The Methodology of Prophet Hood and Now its Imaam Al Mutaghalib? did it suddenly become Immarah of Al Hajjaj?

[2]Jabhat Nusra Also was Part of Jamaah which was doing well Before AlBaghdady broke the Unity, which he also Broke the Bayaah Of The Main Body In AQ central so who is responsible for the shed of this Blood and breaking Jamaah?? 

[3]Abu Baseer Never fought the Islamic state in Madina But Baghdady is Rejecting Orders from the Main Amir so he went Rogue.

[4] if the Uniting Of Muslims is Fardh and Other Sunnahs which Rasoul did at this time are advised not to be done while it has a hadith and Permisabilty for the Fear of Breaking the Muslim Rows , What About Who Breaks the Muslim Ummah Upon A sin?!

and Praise be to Allah Naseeha

Always say 

اللهم أرنا الحق حقا وأرزقنا اتباعه وأرنا الباطل باطلا وأرزقنا ..
Amine Al Shinqity … 

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s